All Incidents
ChatGPT Told a Pastor "God Did Not Design Your Body to Fail." Days Later a Pulmonary Embolism Nearly Killed Him.
BreakingAUG 1, 2026SYSTEMIC FAILURE

ChatGPT Told a Pastor "God Did Not Design Your Body to Fail." Days Later a Pulmonary Embolism Nearly Killed Him.

Scott Winters, a former Florida pastor, has sued OpenAI and CEO Sam Altman in San Francisco County Superior Court, alleging ChatGPT-4o played doctor with none of the accountability. When Winters reported recurring dizziness and blood pressure instability, the chatbot allegedly dismissed his symptoms as minor, told him to stay "recliner-bound," and said he'd need 8 to 10 more episodes before his condition counted as serious. He followed that advice. Weeks later, in July 2025, he suffered a massive bilateral pulmonary embolism that brought him "to the brink of death." One of his own doctors blamed the immobility ChatGPT recommended for triggering the clots. Hours before the emergency, Winters asked the bot whether groin tenderness warranted a hospital trip; it drew on his faith, telling him "God did not design your body to endlessly fail." The complaint accuses OpenAI of the unauthorized practice of medicine and of prioritizing user engagement and profit over safety guardrails. Filed with Tech Justice Law, the Social Media Victims Law Center, and Temple University's Institute for Law, Innovation & Technology, the suit may be the first to test whether product liability and negligence per se can reach a generative AI system's design and deployment decisions.

HOFFICIALHITL Score
HITL Score8/100
Why this matters to youNo jargon — just what it means

Imagine a former pastor who has felt dizzy for weeks, his blood pressure lurching up and down, and the only thing he has to ask for help is a chatbot on his phone. It waves his symptoms away, tells him to stay parked in his recliner, and says he would need eight or ten more scary spells before any of this counted as serious. Hours before everything goes wrong he asks it one more nervous question, and it answers by reaching straight for his faith: "God did not design your body to endlessly fail." Days later a blood clot tears through both of his lungs and nearly kills him, and one of his own doctors says it was all that sitting still that set it off.

Here's why that's a big deal: a computer program with no medical license, no training, and nobody standing behind it played doctor with a real man's life and got it dangerously wrong. A human nurse who told a dizzy patient to sit still and wait for ten more emergencies could lose their license and be sued into the ground. When the machine gives that same deadly advice, there is no license to pull and no one who has to answer for it. This lawsuit is one of the first to ask a simple question: when the software is the one that hurt you, can anyone actually be held to account?

🖤 Explained by Babycakes.
Read the full source →
Source: CBS NEWS (MEGAN CERULLO)